Preparing for a wedding is exhausting, but a broken engagement can be an extremely painful and confusing experience. A man in Australia called off his wedding ten days before the event. Now, he filed a case against his ex-fiancé for not returning the expensive engagement ring.
The man showered his fiance with luxury gifts during their relationship including an engagement ring worth $15,500. However, when he ended the relationship just ten days before the wedding, Edwin Shien Bing Toh demanded fiancé Winnie Chu Ling Su to give all the presents back.
Ling Su, however, doesn’t want to return the engagement ring. The man filed a case against his former partner in a local court in New South Wales. The court documents reveal that the ex-couple first met in 2015 through a mutual friend. They started to go out and planned to marry each other.
It's unclear why the man canceled the wedding but he did it just ten days before the event and everything was already prepared.
A few months after meeting each other, they agreed to open a joint bank account. They also bought a diamond engagement ring for $15,500, a male wedding band worth $500 and a female wedding band for $800. During the relationship, he gave various expensive gifts to his girlfriend including a Longines watch, an iPhone, a diamond necklace, a Samsonite suitcase, and a Louis Vuitton handbag. All the items cost about $5,000.
Months after the proposal, the man canceled the wedding, and he said that everything that belongs to each party should be returned. The woman agreed and asked for his shoes, his wallet, the wedding clothes and the presents her family bought for the man’s parents.
However, when the man asked for his ex-girlfriend to return three rings and five items, she refused. Hence, he brought the case to the local court.
Yet according to a court document, magistrate Rodney Brender found that Toh returned the items to the woman because he felt guilty about calling off the wedding. Though the law about who gets the engagement ring when the wedding is canceled is still unclear, the engagement ring is considered a gift.
The law requires three elements for something to be considered a gift – the giver’s intent to give the item as a present, the giver’s actual giving of the gift, and the receiver’s acceptance.
Moreover, Brender examined English and Australian cases and concluded that since it is no longer allowed to sue for breach of a promise to marry, the engagement ring is considered an unconditional gift.
“An engagement ring still retained the character of a pledge or something to bind the bargain or contract to marry and was given on the understanding the party who breaks the contract must return it.”
“If a woman who received the ring refuses to fulfill the condition of the gift, she must return it, but if the man, without a recognized legal justification, refused to carry out his promise of marriage he cannot demand the return of the engagement ring.”
He also refused the return of the other items, except for the wedding bands. These were ordered to be returned, according to reports.
Who do you think gets the engagement ring? Share your thoughts in the comments section below.
Bees Kill Penguins by Stinging Them in the Eyes
2000 Kilogram Sunfish Caught Off North African Coast
Man Embezzles $57K in COVID-19 Relief to Buy Pokemon Cards
Florida Man Catches and “Recycles” Alligator in Driveway
Man Shocks Reporter on How He’d Spend the Lottery Winnings
Man Joins Search Operation Not Realizing He’s the One Missing
World’s Oldest Rhino Dies in Italian Zoo at 54 Years Old
Meet Quilty – Cat Escape Artist Helping Other Cats Jailbreak
Fans Use American Flag to Save Falling Cat During Football Game in Miami
TikToker Shares How She Tricked Invaders Who Tried Opening The Hotel Door While She Was Alone
Man Iced Neighbor Who Repeatedly Asked Him “When Are You Getting Married?”
Do You Live in One of These 15 Countries With The Most Beautiful Women on Earth?
The Secret Meaning of Anklets And Why Some Wives Wear Them
Waking Up Between 3 to 5 AM Could Mean You’re Experiencing Spiritual Awakening
Divorced Man Wrote 20 Epic Marriage Advice He Wished He Could Have Had
Haunting Photos of Two Tourists Snapped Just Before They Mysteriously Disappeared
“Chastity Cages” is the Latest Thing for Men
Pork Fat Is Officially One of the World’s Most Nutritious Foods
Some Stranger Padlocked This Guy’s Earlobe And Ran Away With The Key
Three-Month-Old Baby Left Blind in One Eye After Family Friend Took His Picture